Law books and gavel

CFTC orders Morgan Stanley Smith Barney to pay USD200,000 for supervision violations

The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission has issued an order filing and settling charges that Morgan Stanley Smith Barney, a futures commission merchant based in Purchase, New York, violated CFTC regulation 166.3 by failing to diligently supervise its employees’ handling of customer accounts.

The CFTC order requires Morgan Stanley Smith Barney to pay a USD200,000 civil monetary penalty and prohibits it from violating CFTC regulation 166.3, as charged.

According to the order, Morgan Stanley had a customer (Customer A) that provided trust services for Customer A’s clients. However, as the CFTC’s order finds, Customer A was itself acting as an FCM without being registered as such, in violation of the Commodity Exchange Act. Customer A acted as an FCM by accepting orders to trade commodity futures contracts on behalf of Customer A’s clients, accepting funds to place those trades, and affecting the trades via a contract market.

According to the CFTC’s order, Morgan Stanley violated CFTC regulation 166.3 by failing to diligently investigate suspicious transactions that were indicative of Customer A acting unlawfully as an FCM. For example, according to the order, from 2006 to 2008 Customer A conducted five transfers of funds from its proprietary commodity futures trading account held at Morgan Stanley to a bank account held by Customer A’s client. These transfers should have prompted Morgan Stanley to question Customer A’s actions and to investigate to determine whether Customer A’s account was being carried properly.

No later than 15 January 2010, Morgan Stanley realised that Customer A’s proprietary futures trading account had been carried improperly since 2006. Nonetheless, Morgan Stanley continued to allow Customer A to function as an FCM, trading on behalf of Customer A’s clients in January, March and May 2010.

According to the order, at the time of the above-described events, Morgan Stanley maintained an inadequate system of supervision and internal controls to detect and deter violations of the CEA and CFTC regulations. Consequently, Morgan Stanley failed to diligently supervise the handling by its partners, officers, employees and agents relating to its business as a CFTC registrant, in violation of regulation 166.3.

Further reading

View all


Upcoming training

Tue, 14/10/2014 (All day) - London