For start-up and emerging managers, successfully launching and running a hedge fund is trickier than ever before. As markets ebb and flow, the level of support provided by prime brokers in the early stages remains critical.
For start-up and emerging managers, successfully launching and running a hedge fund is trickier than ever before. As markets ebb and flow, the level of support provided by prime brokers in the early stages remains critical.
Following the global economic upheaval and market shocks brought about by the Covid-19 pandemic, hedge funds’ selection of service providers has come under ever-closer scrutiny.
The changing picture of the prime brokerage business has seen many PBs reduce the types of services they are willing to offer to managers, while the process of outsourcing across the service provider community has accelerated.
As start-up hedge funds and emerging managers face bigger barriers to entry, the choice of options on offer – whether brand-name PBs or smaller, more boutique outfits – is often influenced by critical cost concerns. Now, more than ever, the process of picking the right prime broker – arguably the most important service provider – could make all the difference between success or failure.
Ashley Wilson, global head of prime services, BNP Paribas
We have an emerging managers policy for funds that are under USD100 million in assets under management that are just starting out. We go through a detailed selection process in terms of the history of the firm and the portfolio manager, and whether we think we can get them from USD100 million to USD500 million with our capital introduction services.
“The thought process I have around emerging managers is that if you are in at the beginning, it’s not the first or second year’s P&L you are looking towards – it’s the future where you think that if you are a day one prime and you have helped them grow to be a large fund, then you have a very deep relationship with that account and you can grow across global markets.
“Capital raising remains key. The number one conversation which has not changed is: ‘How much capital do you think you can help us raise?’”
Eamon McCooey, head of prime services, Wells Fargo
“The emerging manager segment can be challenging in that it may require significant resources in terms of consulting and capital introduction resources from a prime broker that may not pay off given the large turnover in the emerging manager segment. However, if a fund can continue to grow there tends to be a strong relationship and wallet share with the counterparty that helped to launch them.
“One of the key services that emerging managers seek to leverage from their prime broker is capital introduction. Given that many emerging managers launch with capital primarily sourced from friends and family they are looking to expand their potential sources of capital by utilising the investor networks established by prime brokerage capital introduction teams. Often introductions focus on family offices and fund of funds given that large institutional investors can’t invest in emerging managers due to investment guideline restrictions such as minimum investment size or maximum percentage ownership of a fund.
The second key service that emerging managers look to their prime brokers to provide is consulting services. Over the past decade prime brokers have built out their consulting business to provide myriad services to managers of all sizes but with a particular focus to emerging managers. These services include providing overview of service provider capabilities across the outsourced CCO, technology, admin and legal firm offerings. In addition, we see these teams providing managers with budget forecasting tools, marketing strategies, peer group analysis and human capital introductions, all of which are important to a new launch.”
Will Davies, managing director, head of UK sales, Prime Services, Société Générale
“Coming out of Covid, investors may be becoming more interested in meeting new managers, especially as there is more volatility in the market. There are smaller niche managers who have delivered alpha to investors and provide diversification and non-correlation from an investor portfolio perspective.
“We have a strong track record of providing cap intro services for emerging managers, particularly in managed futures where we have helped certain smaller managers and seen them grow to multi-billion-dollar levels. It’s been hard for many managers, especially commodity funds, but commodity volatility right now has created more demand for many of the more commodity-focused funds, which are coming back into vogue.”
Michael Fitzgerald, managing director, Cowen
“Aside from a small handful of very large launches, it is always difficult for new hedge funds to raise money. Yet the number of start-ups last year is roughly on par with the year prior, and so it’s a trend we see continuing – Cowen can be an ideal partner as we can more than handle the core competencies of what they need in a prime broker.
“Newer managers often go from being at a large firm to starting a smaller firm and consequently need to consider all costs related to running their business. They want to make sure they mean something to their partners, and that the hurdle isn’t so insurmountable. They need corporate access, capital markets access, and capital introductions – we’re in the business of making bets smartly on emerging managers, and putting our resources behind them much as our larger competitors do for larger funds.
“We would not suggest that a start-up manager would skimp on building that institutional-style infrastructure, but if they’re going to be launching below a number that requires them to register with the SEC, we often counsel clients to still build an environment, particularly in the compliance area, that enables them to pass an operational due diligence exercise from an institution and Cowen can offer assistance on many operational levels that a manager would otherwise foot the bill for.
“Oftentimes start-up managers look to us as an alternative voice to help them determine what’s pragmatic to launch a business with, so that they can right-size yet also scale, based on what their projected assets are going to be out of the gate.”
Daniel Childs, managing director, Jefferies
“The hedge fund industry – the business of hedge funds – is very much about the relationship that funds have with their investors. Providing hedge funds with intelligence and advice around investors and how to grow assets continues to be an incredibly important part of prime brokers’ offering.”
“The consulting side of prime brokerage is critical. As hedge funds grow, they need to be focusing on different areas. In the early days, it’s going to be about setting up their business; so building a team, helping them trade through, identifying appropriate service providers and raising capital. As a fund matures, interest may pivot to different strategic areas – for example the use of alternative data, ESG impact, identifying partnership opportunities, as well as investor trends. Bottom line is prime brokers should be able to provide valuable advice at every stage of a fund’s life.
“What’s maybe less well understood is the many ancillary pieces which are tremendously important if you are trying to grow and build a hedge fund business. “Prime brokers like Jefferies have the ability to provide a more bespoke offering. Hedge funds care deeply about service and ability to scale. A fund that’s running a few hundred million dollars with 20 staff will have a very different experience working in partnership with a firm like Jefferies that is in growth mode vs a prime broker not looking for growth.”
Read the full Charting New Territory: The future of hedge fund prime brokerage Insight Report here.